run-multiple execution creates output sub folders with alphanumeric value instead of browser names

[AugustineAutoGit]

What are you trying to achieve?

For run-multiple execution with multiple browsers like Chrome, Safari, Firefox and Edge, the subfolder in the output folder should have a name like parallel_Chrome_1, parallel_Safari_2, parallel_Firefox_3 etc

What do you get instead?

While executing using run-multiple the subfolder in the output folder should have name like the following:
parallel_0096a0c740a073d21e23267bf167f711a9826c9d84addc417bc5b320df11e0bd_1
parallel_f7899c9a407a947a824a4955416619aef2c53bd0fbb18965b53d0a3fb4c207d6_2

instead of browser/channel name some alphanumeric value is present in the folder name.

This makes it difficult to do many validations. For eg:
Validating the file download using handleDownloads and FileSystem helper, like using methods I.amInPath('output/folderName');
where folderName is parallel_0096a0c740a073d21e23267bf167f711a9826c9d84addc417bc5b320df11e0bd_1.
This is only 1 example

Provide console output if related. Use --verbose mode for more details.

# paste output here

Provide test source code if related

// paste test

Details

• CodeceptJS version: 3.5.15
• NodeJS Version: 20
• Operating System: Mac OS
• Playwright (if related)
• Configuration file:

# paste config here

[kobenguyent]

I think that's supposed to be like that when you don't explicitly define the outputName

To overcome your issue, try this approach #1722 (comment)

"multiple": {
        "dev": {
            "browsers": [
                {
                    browser: "chrome",
                    outputName: "chrome"
                },
                {
                    browser: "firefox",
                    outputName: "firefox"
                }
            ]
        }
}

[AugustineAutoGit]

Thanks @kobenguyent this fixed my issue of random hash value
For the case of:
Validating the file download using handleDownloads and FileSystem helper, like using methods I.amInPath('output/folderName');
for folderName how should we give?
say now output folders are like parallel_output_1, the runId is dynamic
I tried this way but not working:
I.amInPath('output/parallel_output_*');

[AugustineAutoGit]

Sure

[AugustineAutoGit]

@kobenguyent
1 doubt / suggestion
Is appending runId to the outputDir mandatory, like can we avoid it?
Instead can we append the browser
Since run-mutiple itslef is for parallel testing in multiple browsers can we something like:
outputDir = runName + outputName + browser

For eg: for Playwright browser can be :

• chromium(this can have different channel names like chrome, msedge etc)
• webkit
• firefox

Hence my doubt / suggestion is the possibility of removing runId append and instead adding browser and channel name if any. Like:
outputDir = runName + outputName + browser + channel(only for chromium)

[kobenguyent]

@AugustineAutoGit I think run-multiple command is kinda obsolete and there would be not really active maintenance. It is encouraged to use run-workers command.

[AugustineAutoGit]

@kobenguyent I am using codeceptjs-resemblehelper for visual testing.
This helper won't work with run-workers due to inability to execute in multiple threads.
Sad to know that run-multiple command is kinda obsolete :(
run-multiple was very helpful for me as it is preferred as mentioned in CodeceptJS site for mutliple browser executions.
Our paralle execution requirement is for multiple browsers. Also due to budget constraints not able to use codeceptjs-applitoolshelper

[kobenguyent]

Well @AugustineAutoGit you could raise a PR if you have time to fix it.

[AugustineAutoGit]

@kobenguyent sure will give a try from my side.
Will you provide access or do I need to do a fork
or
if it run-multiple command is kinda obsolete do we need to consider this

Will proceed as per your suggestion

[kobenguyent]

@AugustineAutoGit https://github.com/codeceptjs/CodeceptJS/blob/3.x/.github/CONTRIBUTING.md#contributing

[github-actions]

This issue is stale because it has been open for 90 days with no activity.